3rd February 2024
See What we can do
Introduction: The dynamic landscape of industries is continually shaped by the rapid evolution and expansive product lines they manage. As these sectors navigate the complexities of value chains, the imperative for advanced technology becomes apparent, especially in expediting risk assessment, reducing production time, and facilitating real-time process monitoring. The advent of "Digital Twins" emerges as a transformative solution in this context. This technological innovation involves creating digital or virtual replicas that intricately mirror their physical counterparts, offering a profound capability to predict and diagnose the performance of products or processes.
Digital Twins, a concept introduced by Grieves in 2002, has evolved into a critical tool, owing its development to notable strides in software technologies such as artificial intelligence, the Internet of Things, virtual and augmented reality, and data analytics. This integration of cutting-edge tools with real-world data enables the creation of digital twins that not only simulate real-world entities but also provide insights into future outcomes and address real-time challenges. The widespread acceptance of Digital Twins extends across diverse sectors, encompassing urban planning, complex product design and manufacturing, construction of large-scale structures, and intricate processes within the energy sector.
From my perspective, the transformative potential of Digital Twins lies in their ability to bridge the gap between the physical and digital realms, offering a comprehensive understanding of complex systems. This not only enhances predictive capabilities but also empowers industries to proactively address challenges. The concept's application in urban planning and large-scale construction, for instance, signifies a paradigm shift in how we conceptualize and execute projects, emphasizing a data-driven and simulation-based approach. The convergence of various technologies in the Digital Twins framework showcases the synergy achievable when leveraging the power of interconnected data and advanced simulations. As industries increasingly embrace this technology, its role in fostering innovation, efficiency, and informed decision-making is poised to become even more pronounced in shaping the future of diverse sectors.
Insights: Manufacturing leaders are grappling with two pressing challenges that are causing restless nights: the constraints imposed by escalating costs and talent gaps in both materials and labor, and an urgent need for enhanced production visibility. This demand for improved visibility encompasses various aspects, including more accurate demand forecasting, streamlined inventory processes, increased manufacturing flexibility, and real-time monitoring of the factory floor.
A survey reveals that factory digital twins are emerging as a highly sought-after technology to address these complex issues. Remarkably, 86 percent of respondents across industries recognize the relevance of digital twins for their organizations. A significant 44 percent have already taken the plunge and implemented a digital twin, demonstrating its growing adoption, while an additional 15 percent are actively planning to deploy this technology. This underscores a pivotal shift in the manufacturing landscape, where digital twins are increasingly seen as instrumental solutions to navigate the intricate challenges posed by resource constraints and the imperative for enhanced operational visibility. The survey findings indicate a strong inclination among manufacturing leaders to embrace technological innovations such as digital twins, recognizing their potential to revolutionize not only production processes but also the overall efficiency and adaptability of manufacturing operations. As industries continue to grapple with the evolving demands of the market, the strategic implementation of digital twins appears to be a proactive step towards overcoming present challenges and steering manufacturing into a more resilient and technologically advanced future.
Digital twins operate by leveraging a sophisticated integration of various data sources and organizing technological inputs along a unified data pathway, often referred to as the "tech stack." This tech stack plays a pivotal role in the functionality and effectiveness of digital twins, and for optimal outcomes, it is essential that the tech stack possesses certain key characteristics.
Integration of Data Sources: Digital twins thrive on the amalgamation of diverse data sources, ranging from real-time sensor data and historical performance metrics to external environmental factors. These sources could include IoT devices, data from manufacturing equipment, supply chain data, and more. The integration process involves creating seamless connections between these sources to ensure a comprehensive and holistic representation of the physical system being mirrored in the digital twin.
Common Data Pathway (Tech Stack): The tech stack serves as the backbone of the digital twin system. It encompasses the infrastructure and software architecture that facilitates the flow of data from various sources through a common pathway. This ensures that all relevant data is organized, processed, and made available for analysis in a coherent and structured manner.
Modularity: A modular tech stack is designed with flexibility and adaptability in mind. It allows for the integration of new technologies, data sources, or analytical tools without disrupting the entire system. This modularity is crucial as it enables the digital twin to evolve alongside advancements in technology or changes in the operational environment.
Scalability: Scalability is a fundamental attribute of an effective tech stack for digital twins. It ensures that the system can handle an increasing volume of data and complexity as the scope of the digital twin expands. Whether it's accommodating additional sensors, incorporating more data sources, or scaling up the computational capacity, a scalable tech stack supports the growth and evolving requirements of the digital twin.
Single Source of Truth: A critical aspect of a successful tech stack is its ability to establish a single source of truth. This means that all stakeholders across the organization can rely on the data provided by the digital twin as accurate, consistent, and up-to-date. A unified source of truth fosters trust in the digital twin's insights, enabling better decision-making across different departments and levels of the organization.
In the realm of manufacturing, deploying digital twins involves a strategic approach with a modular and scalable tech stack. Here's a breakdown of key elements:
1. Simulation Software: The tech stack incorporates discrete event simulation software or natively built code, running thousands of scenarios to identify bottlenecks and production constraints. This virtual rendering provides a detailed view of the factory floor's operations.
2. Creating a Standard Language: Data service integration software unites data from disparate streams into a common data pathway, allowing for manipulation and organization into a unified "language." This common data model, facilitated by approaches like UNS, results in a step-change in operational insights.
3. Optimization: Layering optimizer software on the digital simulation enables the twin to run millions of hypothetical production sequences. Advanced approaches like genetic algorithms, Bayesian-based "optionization," and deep reinforcement learning identify optimal sequences, responding to historical patterns and real-time variance.
4. Single Source of Truth (UNS Architecture): A unified name space (UNS) architecture establishes a single source of truth, ensuring data is classified, structured, and accessed consistently. UNS simplifies the complexity of scaling up use cases, ensuring accuracy and reliability.
5. Modular and Scalable Tech Stack:
Modularity: The stack is designed with modular components for flexibility, allowing seamless integration of new technologies.
Scalability: Standardized data integration, APIs, and templates enable easy addition of modular components as the digital twin evolves.
6. Data Sourcing, Storage, and Processing:
Data Foundation: PLCs and MES platforms provide production data, indicating line status, cycle times, and inventory levels. Inventory and demand data, sourced from various streams, are critical components.
Data Cleaning and Structuring: Systematic cleaning ensures modeling consistency. Data is compiled into intermediate tables for consumption by the simulation tool
Embracing a modular and scalable tech stack is not just a technical consideration but a strategic one. It allows manufacturers to adapt swiftly to changing requirements and incorporate emerging technologies seamlessly. The UNS architecture, as a single source of truth, not only streamlines operations but also enhances organizational trust in the accuracy of data insights. The simulation software's role goes beyond mere virtualization; it is a dynamic tool for identifying inefficiencies and optimizing production processes. The integration of optimization software, leveraging cutting-edge techniques like deep reinforcement learning, positions digital twins as powerful decision support systems, capable of driving a new level of performance in real time. In essence, this approach to digital twins transforms them from passive observers to active contributors in the manufacturing landscape. The interconnected tech stack becomes a conduit for innovation, efficiency, and adaptability, heralding a new era where the virtual and physical realms harmoniously coexist for enhanced operational excellence.
Short-term production planning, focusing on weekly or daily production goals, has evolved to meet the dual challenge of timely product delivery and sustainable resource consumption. Manufacturing companies now prioritize not only customer satisfaction but also production efficiency. The complexity of this task has made optimal production planning inherently multi-objective, involving considerations such as backlog production, product-type prioritization, machine capacity, setups, and quality strategy.
The dynamic nature of production systems, influenced by disruptive events and changing priorities, adds an extra layer of complexity. Even a well-optimized production plan may lose its optimality due to unforeseen circumstances. The integration of Digital Twins (DT) has emerged as a valuable solution. By digitally representing the physical system using real shop-floor data, DTs enable a more accurate evaluation of system performance in terms of key performance indicators (KPIs).
Recent advancements in digitalization and smart manufacturing have led to the incorporation of DTs into optimization frameworks for production planning. This integration provides a more precise performance evaluation, considering the dynamic nature of the production system. It facilitates the identification of optimization patterns that offer valuable insights into optimal production strategies.
This further introduces an effective approach for short-term production planning in multi-product systems by integrating a DT with a multi-objective optimization method. The key contribution lies in the optimization algorithm's output, which doesn't just provide a single optimal production plan but a set of optimal plans aligned with specified objectives. This empowers users to implement a production plan with a clear understanding of its impact on all relevant KPIs, ensuring confidence in its optimality.
The challenges faced by modern manufacturing companies, including product replacement, customization, just-in-time concepts, and intelligent production modes, have intensified competition. To stay competitive and resilient to market trends, sustainability and smart innovative solutions are imperative. Efficient management, driven by cost-effective decisions and informed production policies, requires a thorough analysis of system behavior. The aggregation of control and management into a unified system is essential for analyzing and regulating production control policies. Simulation has been a widespread approach for analyzing the behavior of production systems over time. However, the dynamic nature of the manufacturing market demands more than simple simulation models. A resilient simulation model, evolving into a Digital Twin (DT), is crucial. DT, an ultra-realistic and highly scalable simulation, integrates data from shop-floor sensors and uses advanced production management systems. This technology enables the mirroring of real systems, offering intelligent and predictive capabilities for product, process, resource, and operation modeling. The combination of DT with other innovative technologies has the potential to reshape the manufacturing paradigm. Multistage optimization based on DT technology is applied across various business areas, considering aspects such as manufacturing technology, data analysis, process monitoring, and diagnosis. The DT-based optimization strategy involves a repeating cycle practice loop to continuously control and optimize Key Performance Indicators (KPIs).
The adoption of Pareto frontier, inherited from simulation-based optimization, proves useful in the DT modeling-based optimization. It serves as a comprehensible tool for multi-objective optimization. Noteworthy papers have been published in recent years focusing on DT optimization in production systems. Examples include using DT with real-time data gathering for optimizing takt time, cost of operators, and load fluctuation in an air conditioner production line. Additionally, DT-based optimization has been applied to value creation in single and small batch production and part flow management, addressing the challenges posed by customization and personalization trends in manufacturing. These advancements underscore the transformative potential of DT in enhancing efficiency, adaptability, and overall performance in modern manufacturing.
Multi-objective optimization: In the realm of multi-product production planning, decision-makers often grapple with conflicting objectives, necessitating a quantitative evaluation of trade-offs. To address this complexity, a multi-objective optimization method is developed, capturing key parameters of production planning by considering various conflicting objectives. This method integrates alternative policies related to production logistics (lot sizing, production sequencing, part routing, etc.) and policies related to product quality (rework, feedforward control, selective inspection, etc.) within a digital twin's performance evaluation framework.
These policies, modeled with their parameters in the digital twin, undergo evaluation through a multi-objective optimization platform. The goal is to derive the optimal combination of alternative policies. Ultimately, the approach provides optimal combinations of production routing, inspection policies, and defect reduction strategies at each stage of the system, achieving the best trade-off between quality improvement efforts (time) and effective production rate.
The general structure of input information and the output of the multi-objective optimization process are depicted. Input data is sourced from production order management systems, encompassing product types, quantities, and deadlines. Additionally, it incorporates data about the current state of the manufacturing system and parts flowing through it by interacting with the manufacturing execution system. User-defined objectives and technical constraints are also integrated through input data interfaces.
The optimization workflow processes this input data and explores feasible solution spaces guided by algorithms and conditions that model various technical constraints about machines, process KPIs, and other user-defined criteria and objectives. This systematic approach enables decision-makers to navigate the complexities of multi-objective production planning, ultimately leading to optimized
combinations that strike the right balance between different, and often conflicting, objectives.
The application of multi-objective optimization offers significant advantages by enabling the determination of optimal trade-off solutions, known as the Pareto set, while considering competing objective parameters. This approach is crucial as it allows for the improvement of one objective without sacrificing the performance of another criterion. In the context of production planning, a plan is deemed Pareto-optimal if it is not entirely dominated by any other plan. Once the Pareto set is identified, the selection of the preferred solution for the specific case under consideration relies on exogenous factors, outside the computer model, and is carried out by human decision-makers.
In specific industrial cases, Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) indicating the system's objectives can be adapted based on the industrial context. For example, the focus might be on improving product quality by reducing the delay in quality information feedback between critical process stages and tightly controlling material flow routing to reduce process lead time and inventory in the system. The objective is to minimize two objective parameters, and the curve plots represent the best design candidates offering optimal trade-offs between these two objectives. This visual representation aids decision-makers in selecting the most suitable solution based on the specific requirements and priorities of the industrial case at hand.
The application of multi-objective optimization offers significant advantages by enabling the determination of optimal trade-off solutions, known as the Pareto set, while considering competing objective parameters. This approach is crucial as it allows for the improvement of one objective without sacrificing the performance of another criterion. In the context of production planning, a plan is deemed Pareto-optimal if it is not entirely dominated by any other plan. Once the Pareto set is identified, the selection of the preferred solution for the specific case under consideration relies on exogenous factors, outside the computer model, and is carried out by human decision-makers.
In specific industrial cases, Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) indicating the system's objectives can be adapted based on the industrial context. For example, the focus might be on improving product quality by reducing the delay in quality information feedback between critical process stages and tightly controlling material flow routing to reduce process lead time and inventory in the system. The objective is to minimize two objective parameters, and the curve plots represent the best design candidates offering optimal trade-offs between these two objectives. This visual representation aids decision-makers in selecting the most suitable solution based on the specific requirements and priorities of the industrial case at hand
The European Union has long recognized the transformative potential of digital twin technology in revolutionizing the manufacturing sector, and the DIMOFAC (Digital Intelligent MOdular FACtories) initiative stands out as a pioneering effort in this domain. Financed by the EU, DIMOFAC is a groundbreaking research project dedicated to encouraging manufacturers across the continent to integrate digital twins into their operations. Going beyond technological transition, the initiative aims to foster a paradigm shift in manufacturing.
At its core, DIMOFAC leverages the power of digital twins to help manufacturers optimize processes, anticipate challenges, and adjust production parameters in real time. The uniqueness of DIMOFAC lies in its commitment to creating modular and flexible manufacturing systems, enabling industries to respond swiftly to market demands and minimize resource wastage. Early adopters of the insights and methodologies from the DIMOFAC project are experiencing tangible benefits, ranging from shortened production cycles to enhanced product quality.
In the face of increasing competitiveness in the European manufacturing landscape, initiatives like DIMOFAC showcase the EU's proactive approach to equipping its industries with cutting-edge tools for sustained success. The project boasts a diverse group of 30 European partners, including research institutions, tech enterprises, pilot industrial lines, and industry alliances. Over a four-year span, these collaborators are dedicated to devising, trialing, validating, and disseminating a unique industrial approach aimed at expediting the reconfiguration of assembly lines to enhance factory adaptability in response to shifting demands.
Leveraging advanced methodologies such as blockchain, robotics, cloud computing, and AI, the initiative focuses on modeling manufacturing workflows to identify potential areas of improvement. Cécile Girardot, coordinator of the DIMOFAC initiative, emphasizes the role of digital twins in this transition phase, stating, "Digital twins provide real-time data that can show the performance of machines in the real world on a virtual plane." The initiative is set to run until March 2024, contributing to the ongoing transformation of the European manufacturing landscape.
Recommendation; Digital twin technology has emerged as a game-changer in manufacturing, offering virtual replicas of physical systems and enabling real-time optimization. The application of digital twins, as seen in the DIMOFAC initiative, proves crucial in enhancing efficiency, sustainability, and innovation. Businesses should invest in the integration of digital twin technology into their manufacturing processes. This includes developing virtual replicas, leveraging real-time data for optimization, and exploring modular and flexible manufacturing systems. The use of digital twins in manufacturing extends to multi-objective optimization, addressing conflicting objectives and allowing decision-makers to navigate trade-offs effectively. The Pareto set methodology proves valuable in identifying optimal solutions that balance different criteria. Manufacturers should adopt multi-objective optimization methods within their digital twin frameworks. This involves adapting Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) based on industrial requirements and utilizing the Pareto set to make informed decisions. Initiatives like DIMOFAC, backed by the European Union, exemplify a commitment to advancing manufacturing paradigms. By fostering modular and flexible manufacturing systems, these initiatives empower industries to respond swiftly to market demands, reducing resource wastage. Businesses should draw inspiration from initiatives like DIMOFAC and actively seek support from government bodies or industry alliances for the implementation of modular and flexible manufacturing systems. The seamless integration of digital twin factories into Industry 4.0 heralds a new era of manufacturing efficiency, sustainability, and adaptability. As industry leaders showcase the benefits, it becomes evident that the future of manufacturing extends beyond physical factories into the virtual world. Companies should position themselves at the forefront of Industry 4.0 by embracing digital twin factories. This involves strategic investments in advanced technologies, collaboration within industry ecosystems, and a forward-looking approach to navigate the digital manufacturing landscape. The evolution towards Industry 4.0, marked by the transformative influence of digital twin technology and modular factory initiatives, is not merely a trend but a fundamental shift in manufacturing. The integration of digital twins, supported by initiatives like DIMOFAC, offers tangible benefits and positions businesses at the forefront of a new industrial era. The journey towards Industry 4.0 is a strategic imperative, and businesses that strategically embrace these technological advancements will thrive in the dynamic and competitive global landscape.
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)